Mark Schwarzer
v
Elias Figueroa
Schwarzer has been a steady rock in the back for Australia. With a career some 20 years and 109 appearance for the Socceroos, Schwarzer has appeared in 3 World Cups, Uefa Cup twice, and been a team Player of the Year and nearly as long player in the EPL. Schwarzer's abilities can't be looked over, and he can be perhaps considered the best Aussie player ever. He finally announced his retirement this year.
Figueroa has 47 appearances for Chile with two goals to his name at the international level. Perhaps the most visually/spacially aware player in the game in defense, Elias is by far the most storied Chilean player of all time.